Barnwell makes sense of Week 8: One key takeaway from each of Sunday's 11 games

Barnwell makes sense of Week 8: One key takeaway from each of Sunday's 11 games

Sunday of Week 8 of the 2025 NFL season won’t go down as a legendary day of football. After a 27-point blowout of the Vikings by the Chargers on Thursday night, all but one of Sunday’s games were decided by double digits, with the Jets-Bengals shootout as the lone exception. Including that Vikings-Chargers game, 11 of the 12 games we’ve seen so far in Week 8 have been decided by 10 or more points. That 92% clip is the highest for any week going back through 1990.

If the games felt as if they were missing something, they were: starting quarterbacks. Eight of the 24 teams that have played so far in Week 8 weren’t able to start their preferred quarterback. Six of the seven 1 p.m. ET games had at least one backup QB taking the field to start. And Washington’s Marcus Mariota will become the ninth backup to start this week when he takes the field on “Monday Night Football” against the Chiefs. Football usually isn’t this simple, but teams starting backup quarterbacks facing teams starting their preferred quarterback went 1-5 this week, with Tyler Huntley‘s victory against the Bears as the outlier.

Subscribe: ‘The Bill Barnwell Show’

You get the idea: It wasn’t a very fun weekend of games to discuss. At the same time, there were nuggets and moments to enjoy, even if the games weren’t very competitive. Let’s find and celebrate the fun pieces from each of Sunday’s games. A great performance? A cool play? A return to form? There’s at least one takeaway to savor from all 11 matchups.

Let’s start with perhaps the most dominant player in football right now …

Jump to:
TEN-IND | NYG-PHI | NYJ-CIN
DAL-DEN | CLE-NE | SF-HOU
TB-NO | BUF-CAR | CHI-BAL
MIA-ATL | GB-PIT

Jonathan Taylor goes for three touchdowns … again

Ho-hum. Yes, the performance was against a Titans team without star defensive tackle Jeffery Simmons, who might be the only reason people outside of the Nashville area even turn on Tennessee tape most weeks. But when you have four three-touchdown games by the midway point of the season and the rest of the NFL has eight combined, you’re doing something right.

After he torched the Titans for 174 scrimmage yards and three scores on just 14 touches, Taylor can make the case that he’s in the middle of a historic stretch of football. He has scored 10 touchdowns over his past four games. That’s the first time a player has scored 10 or more times over a four-game span since 2015, and Taylor is just the 15th player in NFL history to make it to 10 scores in four weeks of action.

In addition to having five more TDs than anybody else in the NFL (14), Taylor has recorded 3.9% of all the league’s rushing yardage by running backs this season (850). Since 2002, that’s the sixth-highest rate recorded by any back through eight weeks. And a league-best 31% of his touches are turning into first downs or touchdowns.

More than the numbers, what truly signifies a special season for me is seeing how a player can make other NFL players look foolish. Great backs having spectacular seasons, like Saquon Barkley and Derrick Henry a year ago, have a way of making the angles and calculations in other players’ heads go haywire. Defenders are in a panic before they even get to the open field and melt down once they do get there.

Watch Taylor’s 80-yard touchdown run from Sunday and you see the Titans’ defense almost panic as he breaks through the first level of defenders. The Colts’ offensive line — which has done an excellent job of blocking for Taylor across all kinds of different run concepts this season — had no problem creating a hole on a pin/pull sweep, with star guard Quenton Nelson getting to the edge and driving cornerback Darrell Baker Jr. all the way to the sideline. But once Taylor breaks into the open field, Tennessee’s defenders simply have no hope.

play

0:29

Jonathan Taylor takes it all way for an 80-yard TD

Jonathan Taylor scores his second touchdown of the game with the dynamic 80-yard run that has the home fans buzzing.

Safety Xavier Woods starts moving to a spot where he thinks he’ll have a shot at pushing Taylor out of bounds, only to find that Taylor is about 3 yards past that spot once he gets there. Backside safety Amani Hooker is the last hope, but even with Taylor slowed down by Woods’ tackle attempt, the Colts running back is way too fast and prevents Hooker from getting close enough to attempt a diving tackle.

And sure, the Titans’ defense isn’t going to terrify opposing offenses, but Taylor has been doing this all season. He made superstar safety Derwin James Jr. miss on the first of his three touchdowns against the Chargers last week and then broke down Tony Jefferson‘s angle in the middle of the field on his third score. Taylor also shook Brandon Jones to the ground in the open field on his 68-yard run against the Broncos. It’s one thing for a speedster like peak Tyreek Hill to do this to NFL defensive backs. Taylor is 35 pounds heavier than Hill!

Simply put, Taylor is the surest thing in football right now.


Saquon Barkley gets back on track (before getting injured)

There has never really been a reason to think something was missing or lacking in Barkley’s game that was leading the reigning Offensive Player of the Year to struggle in 2025. While Barkley didn’t have a single 20-yard run before Sunday, he did have a 47-yard touchdown catch against Denver, so it was clear there wasn’t some issue with his explosiveness. The Eagles’ offensive line has been banged up and hasn’t been nearly as dominant as it was in 2024, but the real explanation was probably just variance. Barkley ran incredibly hot in 2024 and had maybe been a little unlucky to not have the right hole open up at the right time so far in 2025.

As it turned out, all it took was a game against his former employer, which has the league’s worst EPA per play against designed runs this season, to get Barkley going. He racked up his first two explosive rushes of the season. The one that will stick with Eagles fans as hope that the real Barkley is coming back is the 65-yarder on the opening possession of the game.

play

0:23

Saquon Barkley takes it 65 yards for a TD

Saquon Barkley finds a hole and breaks free for a 65-yard touchdown to give the Eagles a 7-0 lead.

The Eagles are running duo here, where they’re hoping to get double-teams at the line of scrimmage, climb to the second level and isolate Barkley one-on-one against a defender. The line does an immaculate job of blocking this up against an overmatched Giants front; Barkley has to decide whether he wants to hit this into the open gap directly in front of his face or sneak out the back side to take on safety Tyler Nubin.

With Jordan Mailata sealing off Kayvon Thibodeaux and Landon Dickerson climbing to take away Darius Muasau, Barkley doesn’t even need to address a Giants defender until he gets to Nubin, who has had halfbacks run away from him for big gains multiple times this season. It’s not a fair fight. DeVonta Smith has his hands up to celebrate before Barkley even makes it past Nubin and hits midfield. This was the running game the Eagles expected to have in 2025 after everything they showed in 2024, at least for one play.

Barkley then added a 28-yard run on a counter play later in the day, though that was his final carry of the game, as he felt a groin issue start to show up at the end of the run. The three-time Pro Bowler said after the win that he would have been able to come back in and play if the score had been closer. The Eagles were likely wise to sit their star back, especially with Tank Bigsby also joining the 100-yard club on nine carries as Barkley’s primary backup.

As much as this was about Barkley reestablishing his confidence, this might also have been about convincing the offensive line that it can be the same dominant unit we saw a year ago. Before Sunday, carries by Eagles backs were expected to gain an average of only 3.5 yards per run by NFL Next Gen Stats’ model, the third-worst mark in the league. Only the Texans and Browns were worse. Last season, carries by Eagles running backs were expected to produce 4.2 yards per carry, which was ninth best around the NFL.

The Eagles were up at 4.0 expected yards per carry Sunday, their second-best single-game mark of the season. Amid widespread frustrations and concerns in Philadelphia that the Eagles couldn’t reestablish their identity on offense after the loss to the Giants two weeks ago, Nick Sirianni’s team showed that it is capable of being great in back-to-back games. Last week against the Vikings, Jalen Hurts and the passing game led the way with big plays, averaging more than 14 yards per pass attempt and throwing three touchdown passes.

This Sunday, Hurts passed for four more scores but the running game carried the bulk of the load. This was the second-best performance by EPA per snap on offense the Eagles have had since Sirianni took over, trailing only the win over the Commanders in the NFC Championship Game last season. Suddenly, as the Eagles reach their bye week, they appear to be hitting their stride on offense.


Breece Hall has perhaps his last great game for the Jets

We’ll see whether the Jets actually do trade Hall, who is a free agent after the season and a draftee from the now-departed Joe Douglas regime. Sunday gave both sides of a potential Hall trade debate ammunition. Jets running back Isaiah Davis has looked explosive at times over his first 40 pro carries and on Sunday turned 12 touches into 109 yards, including a 50-yard rush where he ran through a Barrett Carter tackle attempt in the third quarter. Trading Hall would open up more opportunities for players like Davis over the rest of a season that isn’t going anywhere, and New York would have a chance to find another back or two next offseason.

And yet, on a day in which the Jets didn’t have Garrett Wilson or Josh Reynolds and were starting an embattled quarterback in Justin Fields (who had been publicly dismissed by his team’s owner), it’s impossible to imagine this team scoring 39 points to win its first game of the season without Hall being the focal point of the offense. Hall ran for 133 yards and two touchdowns before throwing the 4-yard touchdown pass that won the game on a trick play.

I’m not sure there’s a single Bengals defender who didn’t whiff on an attempt to tackle Hall at one point or another during this game. Cincinnati came in with 81 missed tackles, 25 more than any other team in the league, and added to those totals Sunday. Hall ran away from Carter and then flew past Jordan Battle for a 35-yard run in the third quarter. Geno Stone couldn’t get him down on a 5-yard score to end that drive. With the Jets running a dart read concept, pulling a tackle and asking Fields to determine whether he would hand the ball to Hall or keep it himself, Hall outran edge rusher Shemar Stewart before hitting DJ Turner with the classic Lamar Jackson sideline hesitation and scoring from 27 yards out. That got New York back into the game with 8:01 to go.

Jets coach Aaron Glenn also deserves credit for being a little more realistic with his game management after some ill-advised decisions probably cost his team a win over the Broncos in London two weeks ago. New York attempted a fourth-and-1 early and didn’t get it, but Glenn didn’t shy away from an aggressive call later in the game. With the Jets going down by eight after that score at the eight-minute mark, Glenn went for two — a decision supported by the data, as ESPN’s Seth Walder broke down here. They (narrowly) made the 2-pointer on a pass to Davis, and when Hall threw a touchdown pass to Mason Taylor, the extra point won the game.

The Jets were never going to be a good team this season. They’re not going to be in the playoff hunt. Beating a Bengals team that is starting Joe Flacco, can’t tackle and lost Trey Hendrickson during the game to a hip injury isn’t proof that they’re about to go on a winning streak. If it weren’t for Tyrod Taylor suffering a knee injury, Fields would have likely been on the bench, a place he’s still likely to end up later this season.

For the Jets, though, this has to feel like some sort of proof of concept. They were able to run the ball consistently and effectively, and they even hit a few big plays in the passing game without their star receiver. Their coach made what must have felt like an aggressive decision on the sideline, and it worked. The defense allowed 38 points without Sauce Gardner on the field, but it came up with a three-and-out and got the Bengals off the field on downs on the final two drives.

After a week when it felt as if the Jets were essentially giving up on 2025, they suddenly started heading in the right direction. And maybe that encourages New York to hold onto Hall after all.


Guard Quinn Meinerz has a double stack

One week after the Broncos waited three quarters before sparking to life on offense against the Giants, they didn’t take as long to get going against the hapless Cowboys defense. After a rough interception on the opening drive, Bo Nix did just about whatever he wanted for the rest of the day. The Broncos scored touchdowns on six of their next eight meaningful drives, rarely being threatened along the way. Rookie RJ Harvey had his best game as a pro, scoring three touchdowns.

Harvey got some help from his All-Pro guard on his 40-yard score to open the touchdown floodgates. Meinerz is an excellent run blocker, but I usually think about his work at or around the line of scrimmage as the place where he excels. I’d contrast that to someone like Quenton Nelson, who has been incredible pulling and getting out in space to bury linebackers and defensive backs.

Well, things are different now.

play

0:21

RJ Harvey takes off for a 40-yard TD

RJ Harvey dashes in for a 40-yard Broncos rushing touchdown vs. the Cowboys.

Meinerz gets things started early by simply obliterating linebacker Shemar James, who had a target on his back for most of the game. But Meinerz then climbs to the third level and sees safety Alijah Clark, who tries to take the coming hit on and gets driven into the ground. Clark probably wasn’t catching Harvey if he stayed upright, but the safety wasn’t going anywhere once he ran into Meinerz. In a game where it felt as if every Broncos offensive player had a big day, Meinerz might have had the play of the afternoon.

I’ll throw in one negative here: We missed out on a potential NFL record. Brandon Aubrey has arguably the strongest leg we’ve ever seen from an NFL kicker, having made five kicks from 60-plus yards over the past two-plus seasons. It’s clear the Cowboys trust him to hit kicks from just about anywhere in that range, and former coach Mike McCarthy sent him out for a 70-yarder last season, though the kick wasn’t close.

That attempt came in Carolina, though. The Cowboys were playing in Denver on Sunday, where the thin air helps kicks travel farther and expands kickers’ ranges. The weather was warm, and the field was in great shape. This was likely Aubrey’s only chance to kick in the best possible conditions a mile high for a record-setting field goal for as many as eight years, given how the league’s scheduling process works. He might end up on a different team or play a home game in Mexico City, but this was our chance to see something truly spectacular. Could he have hit from 75 yards out?

We never got an opportunity to find out. The Cowboys had the ball on their own 48-yard line with 22 seconds left in the second quarter, which would have been a 70-yard attempt without any additional yardage, but Dak Prescott threw a pick into coverage to end the half. After the break, the Cowboys had a fourth-and-6 on their own 44-yard line, setting up a potential try from 74 yards out. Coach Brian Schottenheimer opted to punt instead, and there was never another chance to get Aubrey in range for a record attempt.

Aubrey maxed out with a 57-yard kick in pregame warmups, but he typically doesn’t try to hit anything from 60 or more unless it’s a game situation. Maybe the former soccer player told Schottenheimer he couldn’t hit from 70 or more. But I sure would have liked to see Aubrey try.


Myles Garrett has a five-sack day

This was a performance that makes you wonder whether Garrett might have wished that he had stuck with his offseason request to be traded. The defense gave Drake Maye some early trouble, but the Browns’ offense lost Quinshon Judkins to a shoulder injury and couldn’t do anything to stay in the contest. And despite getting five sacks from Garrett for the first time in his career, the defense couldn’t repeatedly slow down Maye, who eventually threw for 282 yards, had three touchdown passes and ran for 50 more yards.

To be honest, I’ve actually seen more unstoppable games from Garrett this season. His sacks here weren’t instant wins off the line against overmatched linemen, in part because the Patriots had a clear game plan and tried to give their tackles help. It just didn’t work. There were two sacks where Garrett was chipped by a tight end, got up against Will Campbell and simply teleported past the Patriots’ rookie left tackle. Outside of a deliberately unblocked sack on a boot concept where Maye seemed to think he could outrun Garrett and found out otherwise in painful fashion, Garrett had to work for these sacks.

This was a great example of just how much Garrett or another great pass rusher can do to make life easier for a secondary. While he wasn’t winning instantaneously and completely blowing up plays, the Browns star basically limited Maye to one read or one glance upfield. When Maye held the football or didn’t make an immediate decision, his time was up and Garrett was in position to take him down.

As the game wore on, the Patriots did a good job of pulling out all the tricks good offenses use to slow down great pass rushers. They ran at Garrett. They moved Maye around to change the launch point and avoid making their QB a sitting duck, with Maye going 5-of-6 for 92 yards outside the tackle box. (Without pressure, Maye went 15-of-18 for 235 yards and three scores.) They read Garrett to try to take him out of the play without having to commit a blocker who probably wasn’t going to win. They also took advantage of the moments when Garrett was on the sideline, hitting a 39-yard touchdown pass to Kayshon Boutte without Garrett on the field.

Garrett was spotted slamming his helmet on the sideline in frustration during the game. Afterward, he said what what you might expect: “I would throw the whole performance away for the win.” I don’t blame Garrett for taking what he was offered this offseason. And even if he hadn’t signed a new deal, I’m not sure the Browns were going to move a future Hall of Famer with two years left on his existing contract this spring. It can’t be fun to know, though, that someone can have what most players would consider the game of a lifetime and still not be able to spur the team to at least a close loss, let alone a victory.


Every young Houston playmaker has at least one big play

This was an impressively dominant performance by the Texans. Facing a 5-2 Niners team, the Texans controlled this game from start to finish. Kyle Shanahan’s offense didn’t manage a first down until the final drive of the first half and failed to move the chains even once on six of its nine possessions. One week after his best game of the season, Christian McCaffrey was held to 25 rushing yards on eight carries, while most of the star back’s 43 receiving yards came late in the fourth quarter with the 49ers trailing by double digits. The Texans didn’t let McCaffrey beat them, and no other 49ers player was up to the task of taking over the game.

Without top back in Joe Mixon and their top two veteran receivers in Nico Collins and Christian Kirk, the Texans needed their young offensive playmakers to step up. Mission accomplished. C.J. Stroud delivered his best performance of the season, going 30-of-39 for 318 yards, two touchdown passes and an interception while adding 30 rushing yards in the process. Tight end Dalton Schultz had only 24 receiving yards, so the key runners and pass catchers for the Texans were all players on rookie deals. And they all had big plays.